Shop Etsy

Make Your Valentine a Mixtape (Cookie)

Feb 9, 2021

by Heather Baird

Etsy.com handmade and vintage goods

Editor’s note, January 2021: Looking for an extra-thoughtful way to send good vibes to your valentine? This retro-inspired recipe from our archives is a sentimental and scrumptious way to tell your soulmate, “I’m sweet on you.”

Before iTunes and Spotify were a thing, mixtapes ruled the day. These homemade music compilations allowed the smitten to record an audio love letter—with a little help from David Bowie or Pat Benatar. Today, I’m sharing an edible mixtape cookie that’s the perfect nostalgic gift for your valentine (or anyone that loves the ’80s and ’90s).

You’ll need a few special items to make these cookies. An actual audio cassette tape is necessary, so if you don’t have one, you can purchase new blank cassette tapes online. A standard drinking straw and a wide straw are also used, so if you’ve been thinking of investing in some reusable ones, now’s the time! The edible paper is made of food starch (sugar sheets) and, along with food coloring markers, can be found at most craft stores in the baking aisle.

Mixtape Cookies
Yields 2 dozen

You will need:

Tip: Most used cassette tapes have been collecting dust in the attic for decades, so they’ll need to be thoroughly cleaned before being used on the cookies. First, scrub the surface with a soapy cloth (dish soap is best), then use an alcohol pad to wipe the surface clean. Nooks and crannies should be cleaned with a cotton swab. Finally, wipe the surface again with a clean, damp rag.

Step 1: Make the dough

Mixing bowl filled with wet and dry ingredients.

In an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, mix the butter and sugar together until just incorporated. Do not over-mix at this stage, or the cookies may spread while baking.

Add the egg and vanilla extract. Mix again on low speed, stopping to scrape down the sides of the bowl intermittently as needed.

Mixing bowl after the dough has been combined.

In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour, cocoa, and salt. Add to the butter and egg mixture. Mix on low until dough is formed and there are no longer any streaks of butter in the mixing bowl. The dough will often clump around the paddle attachment while being mixed. This is normal and a good sign that your dough is the right consistency.

Tip: If your mixture is crumbly and not coming together, add cold water one tablespoon at a time until the dough begins to clump.

Dough rolled 1/2-inch thick between two sheets of parchment paper.

Roll the dough to 1⁄2-inch thickness between sheets of parchment paper and chill until ready for use, at least 30 minutes. Preheat the oven to 350°F. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper.

Step 2: Cut dough into cassette-shaped cookies and bake

An audio cassette used to trace and cut a cookie template out of craft paper.
Heather cuts cassette-shaped cookies out of the dough using the cookie template.

Lay the cassette on the craft paper and draw around it, then cut out the resulting shape using scissors. Use this as a template to cut shapes from the dough, then transfer to the prepared baking sheets.

Parchment paper-lined baking sheets featuring rows of rectangular cookies.
Heather uses the standard drinking straw (and the cassette tape as her guide) to punch small holes into each cookie.

Holding the cassette tape over each shape as a guide, use the standard-size drinking straw to cut two holes in each cookie. Chill the cut cookies in the refrigerator for 10 minutes, then bake for 12-15 minutes or until they are fragrant and slightly puffed.

Once the dough has chilled, Heather uses the wide straw to punch out wider holes around the smaller holes.

While the cookies are still warm, use the wide smoothie straw to cut large holes directly over the smaller holes previously cut. Transfer the cookies to a wire rack and allow to cool completely.

Step 3: Create cassette impressions in fondant

A ball of black fondant icing displayed outside of its container.
Heather uses a cassette tape to create impressions in a rolled out piece of fondant.

Knead the fondant well and roll between two pieces of parchment paper until it’s slightly greater than 1⁄4-inch thick. Lay the cassette on the fondant and press down to make a clear impression. Gently lift the cassette from the fondant and repeat, making as many impressions as possible in the space available.

Heather uses a paring knife to cut cassette tape impressions out of the fondant.

Trim around the outside of each impression with a small paring knife. Working one “cassette” at a time, use the large smoothie straw to punch out tape reel holes, then gently turn the fondant over and brush the back with water. Place the fondant onto a cooled cookie, lining up the holes in the fondant to the holes in the cookie. Repeat this process with the remaining fondant and cookies.

Step 4: Cut cassette labels out of sugar sheets and decorate

Edible sugar sheets and mixtape label templates ready to be cut.
Heather uses an X-Acto knife to cut mixtape labels out of sugar sheets.

Print the template provided and lay it on top of a white sugar sheet. Use an X-Acto knife to cut through both the template and the sugar sheet. When finished, peel the cassette label shapes away from the clear plastic sugar sheet backing.

Heather uses food coloring markers to draw designs on her sugar sheet cassette labels.

Using food coloring markers, draw lines on the labels and attach to the cookies with dots of corn syrup or honey.

Allow the cookies to stand for 15 minutes before serving.

The finished mixed tape cookies on display with cups of milk.

If mixtapes are your jam…

Here are four more giftable goodies by Etsy artists that are sure to get you groovin’.

A collage of mixtape-themed gifts available on Etsy.
SHOP (clockwise from top left): Mixtape enamel pin from Emily Ianacone, $9.50; mixtape greeting card from Elizabeth Caparaz, $6; custom mixtape USB from The Blank Record Store, from $23; mixtape gift wrap from Smarty Pants Paper Co., $8

Looking for more creative ways to satisfy their sweet tooth?

These pre-made cookies, baking supplies, and DIY kits are sure to be a heartfelt hit.

A collage of baking-themed Valentine's Day gifts available on Etsy.
SHOP (clockwise from top left): Mini gingerbread house cookies from Euphoria Dessert Shop, from $45 for 6; Valentine’s lace sugar cookies from Sweet 17 Cookies, from $30 for 6; DIY Linzer cookie kit from Red Velvet NYC, $36; heart-embossed rolling pin from Rolling Pin Collection, $18

Shop more Valentine’s Day ideas

Mixtape Enamel Pin
Mixtape Enamel Pin
$9.50 USD
I Love You Card, Love Gift, love card, cassette tape, vintage 90s, 90s mixtape, 1990s, valentine's day card, vintage valentine car, mixtape
I Love You Card, Love Gift, love card, cassette tape, vintage 90s, 90s mixtape, 1990s, valentine's day card, vintage valentine car, mixtape
$5.95 USD
4GB/8GB/16GB USB Mix tape - Retro Personalised Gift -  Rainbow, Birthday, Wedding Present- Boyfriend, Girlfriend, Best friend- Flash Drive
4GB/8GB/16GB USB Mix tape - Retro Personalised Gift - Rainbow, Birthday, Wedding Present- Boyfriend, Girlfriend, Best friend- Flash Drive
$23.36 USD
Edible Gingerbread House, Mushrooms, Mushroom Love Gingerbread House, Edible Mini Gingerbread House, Mushroom Decor, Gingerbread Cookies
Edible Gingerbread House, Mushrooms, Mushroom Love Gingerbread House, Edible Mini Gingerbread House, Mushroom Decor, Gingerbread Cookies
$45.00 USD
Valentine's Heart Lace Sugar Cookies (Set of Six)
Valentine's Heart Lace Sugar Cookies (Set of Six)
$30.60 USD
DIY Baking Kit for Linzer Cookies, perfect for Valentine's Day
DIY Baking Kit for Linzer Cookies, perfect for Valentine's Day
Sold
HEART HAND DRAWN christmas gift, embossed Rolling pin, engraved rolling pin, engraved gift, baby roller, small rolling pin
HEART HAND DRAWN christmas gift, embossed Rolling pin, engraved rolling pin, engraved gift, baby roller, small rolling pin
$17.77 USD

57 comments

Sign in to add your own