Arguably, the best-known cliché about anniversaries is how frequently they’re forgotten. It’s true, anniversaries may often take a back seat to birthdays and bigger holidays — but in terms of gift-giving, they’re among the easiest occasions to shop for. (You can thank tradition for that: it turns out couples have been presenting one another with year-specific tokens of love since the Middle Ages.) Still stumped on what to bestow upon your better half? You’re in luck. Today, we’re offering a selection of handmade and vintage treasures, organized according to anniversary milestone to ensure the perfect pick whether you’re celebrating five years — or fifty. Here’s to many, many more.
Year One: Paper
Pair a classic stationery set and a wood and rubber stamp customized with your initials for a timeless (and useful) first-year gift; from $32.
Record up to ten romantic milestones — first meeting, first kiss, first trip abroad — on the rings of a custom-printed, chalkboard-style tree; from $20.
Give avid readers (and hopeless romantics) a book of long-forgotten love poems from a bygone era; $22.
Year Two: Cotton
Woven by hand using natural cotton yarn, this hammock — which folds down into a handy tote — is perfect for al fresco relaxing à deux; $145.
Snuggle up together under a hand-dyed quilt, made according to traditional shibori technique; $325.
This sweet and sexy nightgown is the handiwork of London-based lingerie designer Joanna Ketterer, whose come-hither creations are crafted from organic cotton, soy fabrics, and salvaged lace; $69.
Year Three: Leather
Shopping for a shutterbug? A personalized leather camera strap is the ideal accessory for memory-making; $39 as-is or from $44 personalized.
Or document daily doings together with a linen-stitched leather sketchbook in the color of your choosing (we’re partial to cheerful marigold); $28.
For him, a revamped Soviet watch from the ’70s with a new leather wristband (and entirely of-the-moment appeal); $94.
Year Four: Fruit or Flowers
Brighten your breakfast table with a pair of whimsical earthenware bowls, shaped by hand to resemble the halves of a cantaloupe; $46 for two.
Keep this botanical print on display at home and you’ll enjoy nature’s beauty year-round (plus, unlike a fresh bouquet, a pressed flower won’t wilt); from $10.
Spread the joy of a love that blooms eternal with heirloom flower seeds; $3.50.
Year Five: Wood
Ditch your standard sparkler for this handmade wooden ring, topped with white resin; $22. (Men’s options include slimmer hand-turned models, minus the bauble.)
Send husband-and-wife duo Ana and Marko a photograph of home sweet home, and they’ll recreate it in miniature from carved wood and acrylic paint; prices vary.
Year Ten: Tin or Aluminum
Plot your next romantic getaway with a vintage tin globe from a favorite era; $245.
Put your love into words with a perfectly patinaed metal bunting, made from repurposed signage strung from twine; $48.
Year Twenty-Five: Silver
Raise a glass of the finest bubbly and keep the rest chilling in a silver-plated champagne bucket (this one’s a relic of 1950s France); $35.
Commemorate a quarter-century of being in step with made-to-order mirrored oxfords — just right for a celebratory spin on the dance floor; $42.
What better reminder of the family tree you’ve created together than an earthy aquamarine-and-sterling silver ring, cast from a real tree branch; $75.
Year Fifty: Gold
Fête fifty with a scratch-off golden ticket redeemable for an extravagant adventure abroad; card $9 (vacation bill varies).
Here’s another gilded go-to for announcing a major getaway: a solid gold ring engraved with the coordinates of your destination; from $225.