Shop Etsy

4 Scary-Good Halloween Treats You Have to Eat to Believe

Oct 21, 2019

by Katie Hawley

Etsy.com handmade and vintage goods

While the grocery store candy aisle is a perfectly suitable source for the stuff you’ll leave out for the trick-or-treaters, to limit your Halloween snacks to those supermarket standbys would be a grave mistake. Even if your plan is to keep your family festivities relatively low-key, you can still go big with a bewitching refreshment table. Read on to discover four scary-good treats guaranteed to make this year’s Halloween hang extra sweet. Try one, or go all-out for a wickedly delicious spread.

A macabre cake

A homemade red velvet skeleton cake
A homemade red velvet skeleton cake

If you’re in the market for an eye-catching confection that’s equal parts twisted and tasty, this delicious red velvet skeleton cake will not disappoint. Slice it open for a creepy surprise that’s certain to give everyone a good scare. Difficulty level: advanced 

Enchanting baked broomsticks 

Homemade pretzel broomsticks
Homemade pretzel broomsticks

Calling all fans of bewitching bakes: These two-ingredient pretzel and phyllo dough broomsticks are the magical appetizers you’ve always dreamed of conjuring. Keep your presentation classic with a savory nacho cheese dip, or opt for sweet and add a finishing cinnamon sugar flourish. Difficulty level: easy 

A spellbinding cocktail

Green poison apple cocktails served in martini glasses
Green poison apple cocktails served in martini glasses

Dubbed the Poison Apple, this adult-approved elixir is the perfect concoction to round out your Halloween spread. Serve it with dry ice and a black sugar rim to up the supernatural factor—cauldron optional. Difficulty level: easy

An edible haunted house

Assembling the base of a haunted gingerbread house
A completed haunted gingerbread house

Made with black cocoa powder and muscovado sugar, this edible haunted house is deceptively delicious. Doubling as decor and dessert, this break-and-eat haunted mansion takes grandma’s gingerbread house to the dark side. Difficulty level: advanced

Top off your creep-tastic tablescape with these eerily charming glasses, bowls, and personalized pumpkins made by Etsy sellers.

SHOP (clockwise from top left): Personalized pumpkin from Molly Ward Creative, $10; macabre rocks glasses from Counter Couture Design, $48 for set of 4; ceramic vampire bat bowl from Barruntando, $40; hand-painted tree branch wine glasses from Mary Elizabeth Arts, $49 for set of 2

Shop more spooktacular Halloween ideas

Personalized Pumpkin, Custom Pumpkin, Orange Pumpkin, Small Pumpkin, Porch Pumpkin, Fall Porch, Fall Decor, Halloween Decor, Lettered
Personalized Pumpkin, Custom Pumpkin, Orange Pumpkin, Small Pumpkin, Porch Pumpkin, Fall Porch, Fall Decor, Halloween Decor, Lettered
$10.00 USD
Halloween Glasses - Macabre 11oz. Glass Set - Anatomical Heart - Halloween - Skull - Scarab Beetle - Death Head Moth - Metallic Foil - Goth
Halloween Glasses - Macabre 11oz. Glass Set - Anatomical Heart - Halloween - Skull - Scarab Beetle - Death Head Moth - Metallic Foil - Goth
$48.00 USD
Halloween Special Ceramic Black Vampire Bowl for your Halloween Decor Halloween party. Made to Order
Halloween Special Ceramic Black Vampire Bowl for your Halloween Decor Halloween party. Made to Order
$47.80 USD
Halloween Glasses, Halloween Decor, Spooky Black and White Halloween Trees - Set of 2 Hand Painted Halloween Wine Glasses
Halloween Glasses, Halloween Decor, Spooky Black and White Halloween Trees - Set of 2 Hand Painted Halloween Wine Glasses
$49.00 USD

62 comments

Sign in to add your own